[email protected] +1.646-694-2643

All Posts

My SQF Audit Starts at the Gate (Oh Yes, Right There!)

Nov 21, 2026 · 9 min read

My name is Persimony (not my real name, but stay with me), and I am an SQF auditor. When I go to a site, my audit starts the minute I reach the gate, the street, or the area around the building. Oh yes, the audit starts right there!

You may think your audit begins at the opening meeting, with coffee and a nice binder. Sweet thought. By the time I shake your hand, I have already met your dumpster.

7:52 AM: The Parking Lot

I pull in and look around like a tourist with a clipboard. Is the dumpster lid closed, or is it hosting a buffet for every bird in the county? Are there old pallets stacked against the wall, giving pests a five-star hotel? Is there standing water, tall grass, or a mystery pile of equipment that "we're getting rid of next week"?

I also notice the employee door propped open with a bucket. That bucket is famous. Every site has one. Your pest control company knows that bucket, and now so do I.

8:01 AM: The Lobby

Next comes the visitor sign-in. Do you ask me about illness? Do you tell me the rules on jewelry, hairnets and where I can and cannot go? If the receptionist hands me a hairnet and says "you probably don't need this," I smile, put it on, and write a small note in my heart.

8:15 AM: The Opening Meeting

Now we gather in the conference room, and I do a quick head count. Not of the donuts. Of the people.

Who is at the table? Is it site management? The plant manager and the SQF practitioner? Or only the FSQA team, sitting close together like the last three people at a party? Where is the GM? Where is the CEO? Not here yet? Stuck in traffic? Having his or her own meeting down the hall, about something "much more important"?

Sometimes the plant manager pops in, says "Welcome, anything you need, just ask," and disappears for the rest of the day like a magician. Sometimes the GM arrives at 8:40, coffee in hand, asking, "So what did I miss?" And sometimes, my favorite, the whole leadership team is there on time, phones face down, ready to talk. I notice all three.

Here is why. Edition 9 of the SQF Code expects senior site management to lead the food safety system, provide the resources it needs and support a real food safety culture. Who shows up to the opening meeting tells me a lot about who owns food safety at your site. If the SQF practitioner is holding the whole system alone, like a waiter carrying twelve plates, I will see it.

So I ask friendly questions. When was your last management review, and what did it decide? Who covers for the SQF practitioner during vacation? If the answer is "nobody, we just hope," we will talk.

9:00 AM: The Floor Walk, My Favorite Part

Hairnet on. Beard net if needed. Smock, ear plugs, safety glasses, my most curious face. Let's go.

First rule of the floor walk: who walks with me, talks with me. So who is walking with me today? Who is leading and who is following? Sometimes the SQF practitioner leads, confident, explaining every step. Sometimes the plant manager leads and the SQF practitioner follows three steps behind, whispering corrections. And sometimes we get a small parade: four people behind me, one in front, and one who keeps "going ahead to check something." I know what that one is doing. They are running ahead to close the door, move the pallet and wake up the line.

And who is looking at me? Everyone. The operators are looking at me. The supervisor is looking at the operators looking at me. Someone is texting, "The auditor is in the packing room." Don't worry. I see it. I do have eyes behind my head, you know.

Then there is my favorite moment of every audit. I walk up to an operator, smile and ask, "Can you show me how you check the metal detector?" Suddenly, this person, who was chatting happily with a coworker a second ago, doesn't speak a word of English. Not one. Nada. But when I try my best Spanglish, "¿Me puede show me the test piece, por favor?" everything is understood perfectly. We laugh, they show me, and honestly, they usually do it better than the procedure describes.

The serious point behind the joke: procedures, training and signs need to be in the languages your people actually work in. And if the floor speaks Spanish, bring someone on the walk who can translate. Your operators know their jobs. Give them a way to show me.

While I'm out there, I watch everything:

  • The hand wash sink. Real scrubbing, or the famous two-second wave? Is there soap, paper towels and hot water, or is the sink being used to store a box of gloves?
  • The jewelry check. A wedding band is one thing. A full set of earrings, a watch and a fitness tracker under the glove is a whole accessories store.
  • The magic clipboard. I ask to see the monitoring log at the line. It isn't there. Then a few minutes later it appears, fully filled out, still warm.
  • The allergen corner. Is the allergen ingredient labeled, stored where it belongs, and kept away from everything else? Or is it sitting on the top rack, right above the product that must not contain it?
  • The gap under the door. If a mouse could stroll in wearing a backpack, I will measure it with my eyes and my flashlight.
  • The tape and the zip ties. Blue tape holding a guard on, zip ties holding a hose together, cardboard covering a hole. Temporary repairs love to become permanent residents.
  • The sudden cleaning. The line that was running when I arrived is now being cleaned with great enthusiasm. That's lovely. I will still ask when it was last cleaned before today.

I am not trying to catch anyone. I just want to know whether your food safety system lives on the floor or only in the binder. If the procedure says hourly checks with three test pieces, and the operator shows me one test piece and says "we do it when we remember," the binder and the floor are not on speaking terms. In any language.

11:30 AM: The Records Room

Now I compare what I saw with what you wrote. Records should be complete, signed by the person who did the work, and reviewed by someone who can act on them. I have seen beautiful monitoring logs, every entry in the same pen, same handwriting, perfectly lined up, for three weeks in a row. Records that neat make me nervous. Real records have a coffee ring and the occasional correction, done properly with a single line and initials.

I also check that your food safety plan matches the line I just walked. New equipment, new product, new ingredient? Then the flow diagram and hazard analysis should show it was reviewed. A flow chart from three line changes ago is like using a map from before the highway was built.

1:00 PM: Lunch, and Then Corrective Actions

After lunch, I look at your internal audits and corrective actions. I love this part, because it shows me whether you fix problems or just repaint them. Good corrective actions have a correction, a real root cause, a preventive action that addresses that cause, and proof that the fix worked.

My least favorite root cause in the world is "employee error." My second least favorite is "retrained the employee." If the same finding shows up again two months later, the employee was not the root cause. The system was.

2:00 PM: Sanitation and Environmental Monitoring

First, the sanitation part. I check the master sanitation schedule, the cleaning procedures, and how you verify that the cleaning actually worked, not just that someone signed the sheet.

Then I ask my favorite question of the afternoon: "So, tell me about your environmental monitoring." And I watch faces. Is it ATP swabs? APC? Listeria? Salmonella? Or "you know, the swabs"? ATP tells you whether a surface is clean. It does not tell you whether you have a pathogen problem. Those are different tests for different questions, and your program should know which is which.

Next: where are your locations? Do I see Zone 1 to Zone 4 on paper, with the same ten spots swabbed every week since the program was born? Or do I see a sampling plan built on risk: the drains, the hollow rollers, the cracked floor under the line, the spot where condensation drips when nobody is looking? Bugs do not read your zone map. They live where it is wet, warm and hard to clean.

And then the real question: what are your bugs doing? Are they dancing a conga line from the drain to the conveyor? Taking you round the mulberry bush with a positive, a negative, a positive, a negative? Have they signed a long-term lease in the floor drain and started inviting friends? Or do they know you mean business, because every positive gets a corrective action, intensified swabbing, a root cause and three clean results before anyone relaxes?

An environmental monitoring program that collects results and never follows up is like a smoke detector with no battery. It looks great on the ceiling. I want to see the trend, the follow-up and the day you finally evicted that tenant.

2:45 PM: Supplier Approval

On my way through the warehouse, I picked a bag of something. I always pick a bag of something. Now I ask you to show me that its supplier is on your approved supplier list, with current documents and a specification. "Purchasing handles that" is not a document.

3:30 PM: Training

Training records matter, but a sign-in sheet does not prove anyone learned anything. Earlier, when I asked people on the floor what they do and why, they were taking my favorite kind of test. The kind where they don't know it's a test. An operator who can explain their critical control point tells me more than a stack of signatures.

4:30 PM: The Closing Meeting

Finally, we sit down and I go through what I found. Most nonconformances I see come from the same handful of places:

  • Procedures that say one thing while the floor does another
  • Missing, late or unsigned monitoring records
  • A food safety plan that was not updated after a change
  • Corrective actions with no real root cause or verification
  • Calibration that is missing or overdue
  • Suppliers who are not on the approved list
  • Environmental monitoring results with no follow-up
  • Recall and traceability procedures that were never tested
  • And yes, the famous propped-open door

Then I drive away. And as I pass the gate, I look at the dumpster one last time. Old habits.

Persimony's Advice: Audit Yourself First

Here is my secret. The sites that do best are the ones that walk their own property like an auditor before I ever arrive. Start at the gate. Close the dumpster. Retire the bucket. Trace a finished product back to its ingredients and suppliers. Ask your operators to explain their tasks. Check that last year's findings have not quietly moved back in. A good internal audit or mock audit a few months before certification gives you time to fix things properly, not just tidy them up the night before.

Get Ready With L & A Consults

Persimony may be made up, but the audit is very real. Whether you are going for SQF certification for the first time or preparing for recertification, we can help you see your site the way an auditor will. We offer gap assessments, mock audits, corrective action support and free onsite consultations to learn about your needs. Our Virtual Classroom Internal Auditor Course trains your own team to audit like the pros.

Email us at [email protected] to get started, or learn more about our SQF consulting services.